| | |

What I Bought Versus What I’m Keeping From The NSale

This post may contain affiliate links which won’t change your price but will share some commission. As an Amazon Influencer, I earn from qualifying purchases. Some products might be gifted from brands.

I buy a lot of clothing! Almost everything I buy is online since there aren’t many stores near me. I can’t keep everything, and a lot of the clothing is returned for various reasons. Some things don’t fit me right, and the size I bought can be off. Other times, the colors look different in person or don’t go great with my complexion. If the item fits and looks good on me, then I have to decide if I will have the opportunity to wear it enough to warrant the purchase. I end up keeping waaaay more than I probably should. So, today, I’m sharing what I bought versus what I’m keeping from the Nordstrom Anniversary Sale.

The Nordstrom Anniversary Sale ends tomorrow night, so I wanted to make sure you had one more time to grab your favorites at a discounted price. I use the sale to buy from brands I love but don’t like paying the full purchase price, and prices will go back up on the 5th. I may not have champagne taste on a beer budget, but it is definitely on a wine budget. Lol!

What I bought at Nordstrom - Wide leg jeans from Caslon 2
With Ease Tee (Small) | Caslon® Drawstring Wide Leg Chambray Pants (Medium) | Oversize Buckle Suede Belt (Medium) | Small Allington Tote | Caviar Platform Slide Sandal (TTS) | | Lex Chain Necklace in Gold | Lex Chain Bracelet in Gold 

Here is a new purchase from the Nordstrom Anniversary Sale. I’m still buying items, and the Caslon® Drawstring Wide Leg Chambray Pants are already a favorite, even though this is the first time I tried them on. I mentioned them in my Best Pants To Wear To Survive The Heat post and ordered them for myself.

The pants are lightweight, flowy, have pockets, are comfortable, and look amazing. Plus, they are on sale for under $45. The only negative is that they are long. I’m 5’6″ tall and wear a 32″ inseam, and I need to wear a heel with these. Maybe I just got a tall size by accident.

The With Ease Tee is not from Nordstrom, but I knew you would want the links. This is an oversized, very soft, and comfy tee.

I’m keeping this entire outfit from head to toe! It is a winner in my book!!!

What I bought at Nordstrom - Wide leg jeans from Caslon10
What I bought at Nordstrom - Wide leg jeans from Caslon4
What I bought at Nordstrom - Wide leg jeans from Caslon12
What I bought at Nordstrom - Wide leg jeans from Caslon14
With Ease Tee (Small) | Caslon® Drawstring Wide Leg Chambray Pants (Medium) | Oversize Buckle Suede Belt (Medium) | Small Allington Tote | Caviar Platform Slide Sandal (TTS) | | Lex Chain Necklace in Gold | Lex Chain Bracelet in Gold 

What I Bought Versus What I’m Keeping

Recent Finds at Nordstrom - black short sleeve tee, a houndstooth blazer, and jeans2
Cotton Crop T-Shirt (Large) | Houndstooth Double Breasted Blazer (Size 10) | Le Easy Flare Raw Hem Jeans (Size 28) | Colette Large Hoop Earrings | Lex Chain Necklace in Gold | Lex Chain Bracelet in Gold | Rebecca Minkoff Leather Tote | Sam Edelman Pointed Toe Pump (TTS)

This outfit was in my Fabulous Finds From Nordstrom That You Can Buy Now post. You can read more about all the items there. For this look, I’m keeping all of it. The only item that I’m on the fence about is the Rebecca Minkoff Leather Tote. I love the handbag, but I’m not sure I would carry it enough since I don’t work outside the home. But, dang…it sure looks sharp! You can read about this outfit here.

Recent Finds at Nordstrom - blue textured shell, a long blue cardigan, and jeans11
Rib Sleeveless Sweater (Medium) | Open Front Longline Cardigan (Medium) | Le Easy Flare Raw Hem Jeans (Size 28) | Colette Large Hoop Earrings | Lex Chain Necklace in Gold | Lex Chain Bracelet in Gold | Sam Edelman Pointed Toe Pump (TTS) | Leather Small Allington Tote

It might have been easier to say what I’m not keeping. Lol! I’m keeping this entire outfit! Someone asked if long cardigans are going to be trending this year, and I have no idea. There are some items I love wearing, and they look great on me, so I don’t care if they are trending. What do you think about this outfit? You can read about this outfit here.

Recent Finds at Nordstrom - Barefoot dreams loungewear PJs 6
CozyChic® Ultra Lite® Knit Pajamas (Large) | Colette Large Hoop Earrings | Lex Chain Necklace in Gold | Lex Chain Bracelet in Gold 

This is a maybe. Yes, I intend to keep these Barefoot Dreams knit pajamas, but I’m not sure I’m keeping this exact pair. I’ve ordered a medium to see if it will fit better, and they will arrive on Monday. This pair seems a tiny bit too big, but I’ll decide which set I’m keeping once the other ones arrive. You can read about this outfit here.

Maroon outfit from Eileen Fisher at Nordstrom 1
Crewneck Boxy Rib T-Shirt (Small) | Rib Wide Leg Ankle Pants (Small) | Colette Large Hoop Earrings | Lex Chain Necklace in Gold | Lex Chain Bracelet in Gold | Sam Edelman Pointed Toe Pump (TTS) | Large Kensington Quilted Suede & Leather Shoulder Bag

We have finally found an outfit that includes items I’m sending back. I plan on keeping the Quilted Suede and leather Shoulder Bag and the Pointed-Toe Pumps, but the Eileen Fisher T-shirt and wide-leg pants are going back. I don’t find them flattering enough to justify the purchase. You can read all the details of the look here.

Recent Finds at Nordstrom - Long sleeve tee and jeans20
Long Sleeve Organic Cotton T-Shirt (Large) | Twist Raglan Cardigan (Medium) | Rider High Waist Ankle Slim Straight Leg Jeans (Size 30) | Colette Large Hoop Earrings | Lex Chain Necklace in Gold | Lex Chain Bracelet in Gold | Longchamp Expandable Recycled Nylon Tote | Suede Havan Loafer Mule (TTS)

This outfit is a mixture of keeping and returning. I’m definitely keeping the long-sleeve T-shirt, Barefoot Dreams cardigan, and Loafer Mules. The Longchamp Expandable Recycled Nylon Tote is going back because I already own something similar and wouldn’t use this one enough. I’m undecided about the Slim Straight Leg Jeans since I already own a pair of Mother jeans in this exact color. Would I really wear these enough??? You can read all the details of the look here.

All black outfit from Eileen Fisher at Nordstrom 20
Crewneck Rib Sweater (Small) | Rib Wide Leg Ankle Pants (Small) | Colette Large Hoop Earrings | Lex Chain Necklace in Gold | Lex Chain Bracelet in Gold | Clear Strap Wedge Shoes (Size 9.5) | Leather Small Allington Tote

I’m keeping all the jewelry and the Clear Strap Wedge Shoes and Leather Small Allington Tote. Like the Blackberry Eileen Fisher outfit above, I don’t find this style particularly flattering on me. It is comfy and feels great, but I don’t think I would wear it enough. You can read all the details of the look here.

What I Bought Versus What I’m Keeping

Over 50 Fashion Blogger, Tania Stephens, is wearing a sweater and white tee and a denim skirt from the Nordstrom Anniversary Sale-2
Le Mid Rise V-Neck T-Shirt (Medium) | Patch Pocket Button Front Denim Skirt (Size 8) | Caviar Platform Slide Sandal (TTS)

The V-Neck T-Shirt is going back, but I’m keeping everything else. I kept the AllSaints Cotton Crop T-Shirt in white and black, so I couldn’t justify buying this one. The Denim Skirt is versatile, and I think I’ll wear it a lot this fall, so it is staying. It is also super soft and stretchy, and it looks and fits great. You can read about this outfit here.

Over 50 Fashion Blogger, Tania Stephens, is wearing a sweater and pleated skirt from the 2024 Nordstrom Anniversary Sale-2
Crewneck Cashmere Sweater (Large) | Pleated Midi Skirt (Medium) | Avani Slide Sandal (TTS)

I’m keeping the Cashmere Sweater, but the Pleated Midi Skirt is going back. I can’t see myself wearing this enough since I don’t have any upcoming events, and I hate to just keep it hanging in the closet. This is a hard one to send back since I think it is GORGEOUS! You can read about this outfit here.

Over 50 Fashion Blogger, Tania Stephens, is wearing a black sweater and jeans from the 2024 Nordstrom Anniversary Sale-237
Crewneck Raglan Cotton Blend Sweater (Medium) | Le Easy Flare Raw Hem Jeans (Size 28) |  Franco Sarto Bootie (8.5)

This outfit is a keeper from head to toe! I love the sweater, and I bought it in two colors. The jeans fit great, and I like the light-wash look. The Franco Sarto Booties are a great neutral for fall, and I like the 2″ kitten heel. I sized down a 1/2 size in these, so remember that if you are between sizes. You can read about this outfit here.

Recent Finds at Nordstrom - Long sleeve tee, free people sweater, and jeans8
Cable Stitch Pullover Sweater (Medium) | Long Sleeve Organic Cotton T-Shirt (Large) | Mother Mid Rise Flare Jeans (Size 29) | Colette Large Hoop Earrings | Lex Chain Necklace in Gold | Lex Chain Bracelet in Gold | Suede Havan Loafer Mule (TTS)

I’m keeping the long-sleeve T-shirt since I don’t have one in my closet. I’ll also keep the loafers, which are a great summer-to-fall transition shoe. When the weather starts to cool off, you want to have your toes covered. These mules will keep your foot cool since the back is open, so they are the best of both worlds. You can read about this outfit here.

Over 50 Fashion Blogger, Tania Stephens, is wearing jeans and a sweater from the Nordstrom Anniversary Sale -24
Short Sleeve Wool & Cashmere Sweater (Large) | Ankle Straight Leg Jeans (Size 29) | Small Allington Tote | Kitten Heel Pointed Toe Slingback Pump (Size 9) | 55mm Gradient Square Sunglasses

I’m keeping the Vince Short Sleeve Wool & Cashmere Sweater, which I also bought in the color Nile. I bought this same sweater last year in black and burgundy, so you can tell I love it. I’m also keeping the Tote and Slingback Pumps. The Straight Leg Jeans are a smidge too big for me, and the next size down has sold out. I hate to, but I’m sending these back. If they don’t fit correctly, I won’t wear them. You can read about this outfit here. I didn’t end up buying the sunglasses, so they don’t have to be returned.

What I Bought Versus What I’m Keeping

Over 50 Fashion Blogger, Tania Stephens, is wearing jeans and a tee from the 2024 Nordstrom Anniversary Sale - 10
Cotton Crop T-Shirt (Large) | Open Front Longline Cardigan (Medium) | High Waist Flared Wide Leg Jeans (Size 29)

It’s a KEEPER!!! I love everything about this outfit. The tee is a great weight and not see-through, the cardigan is a fabulous neutral color, and the wide-leg jeans are the perfect width. You can read about this outfit here.

Over 50 Fashion Blogger, Tania Stephens, is wearing a sweater skirts and top from the Nordstrom Anniversary Sale -4
Cable Crop Cardigan (Medium) | Cable Sweater Skirt (Medium) | Cristen Knee High Boot (TTS)

This will probably be going back. I like the cable knit design and the color of the set, but I have a similar sweater set, and I can’t justify having both. You can read about this outfit here.

Over 50 Fashion Blogger, Tania Stephens, is wearing a red coat from the Nordstrom Anniversary Sale-2
Nadya Tie Waist Satin Jumpsuit (Large) | Double Breasted Belted Coat (Medium) | Hazel Pointed Toe Pump (TTS)

The jumpsuit is going back, but the Double Breasted Belted Coat and pumps are staying. This coat is gorgeous, and I love the red, but it is also available in several other colors. You can read about this outfit here.

Over 50 Fashion Blogger, Tania Stephens, is wearing a faux leather dress and boots from the Nordstrom Anniversary Sale -22
Faux Leather Shirtdress (Medium) | Cristen Knee High Boot (TTS)

Everyone loved this dress on me, including me. BUT, I don’t think I’ll wear it enough to keep it. The dress fits me great and is of nice quality. I’m undecided about the boots, but the dress is going. You can read about this outfit here.

Cotton Crop T-Shirt (Large) | Flat Front Straight Leg Pants (Size 8) | Oversize Buckle Suede Belt (Medium) | Kitten Heel Pointed Toe Slingback Pump (Size 9)

The only thing I’m on the fence about is the Straight Leg Pants. They look great in this photo, but I thought they were too big on me when I looked in the mirror. I’m going to have to try them on again and make a decision. The rest of the outfit stays! You can read about this outfit here.

What I bought from the Nordstrom NSale
Callie Sheer Knit Cotton Top (Medium) | ‘Ab’Solution High Waist Itty Bitty Bootcut Jeans (Size 8) | Hazel Pointed Toe Pump (TTS)

I love everything about this outfit. I’ve owned these jeans for years, and I still wear them a lot. The Varley sheer top is gorgeous, but you’ll need a cami or tank underneath. The color I’m wearing is no longer in stock, but I linked to the exact same sweater in almost the exact same color. The sweater does run big, but I like the oversized look.

The Beauty Items I’m Keeping

Beauty Products I Love - Trish McEvoy
The Power of Makeup® Dare To Be Gorgeous Makeup Planner

This is a keeper!!! I’ve been using this almost every day since I bought it. I don’t care for the tubular mascara because I don’t like that kind of mascara. But, for the most part, I love all the items included in this Makeup Planner. You can read about all the beauty products here.

Beauty Products I Love - Bobbi Brown eyeshadow and mascara1
Bobbi Brown Eyeshadow Palette & Mascara Set

I’m loving this set by Bobbi Brown. The eyeshadow palette has beautiful shades, and the shadows stay put. I’ve only used the mascara once or twice since I’m using one from the planner above.

Beauty Products I Love - Benefit eyebrow pencil and setting gel
Benefit Big Time Brow Minis Set

I use this set daily! The brow get is the best I’ve found, and the hairs on my brows stay put. This is especially useful for days I’m taking photos and pulling shirts over my head a lot.

MAC Full-Size Fix+ Setting Spray Set

I’m keeping this set even though I’ve not yet opened it. I use Fix+ Setting Spray, and I have for years. I already have a bottle that I’m using, so I haven’t opened this one yet…but I will!

Beauty Products I Love - Laura Mercier Cream Eyeshadow Trio
Laura Mercier Caviar Stick Eyeshadow Trio

I kept this Eyeshadow Trio and sent back a different set. This set is the shades I like for my blue eyes, and the shadows stay put the entire day.

Beauty Products I Love - Kiels Exfoliating Soap
Fatigue Scrubbers Trio

I love it when Joe ends up using my products! My skin is extremely, so I love an exfoliating soap. This one is gentle, but has enough grit to it to exfoliate the dead skin. Joe used it a time or two and pronounced it a keeper. He loves the way it lathers, and I love the exfoliation, so it is a keeper.

Beauty Products I Love - Moon Teeth Whitening
Moon Teeth Whitening Device

I’ve been using this, and Joe noticed my teeth starting to look whiter. He asked what I was doing, and guess who is also using it now. Lol! I ordered more whitening strips since he had decided to use this also. I love the fact that the device only takes 5 minutes and that the strips are dissolvable. Because they are dissolvable, they will stick to your lips when you first put them on. Just use your tongue to wet them and insert the tray, then you’ll be fine.

Nest Fragrance Duo1
Grapefruit & Bamboo Reed Diffuser Duo

Joe loves this product, too. He is sooo funny about some things. He wants the house to smell good, but he doesn’t like candles. This has been a good compromise, and the diffuser smells great and looks gorgeous.

There are more items than this that I kept, but I’m sure you are already worn out and ready to place your order before everything sells out. Good luck, and don’t forget that the prices will go back up on Monday the 5th!

Whenever you SHARE my posts on PINTERESTINSTAGRAMYOUTUBE, AND FACEBOOK, it helps other ladies who might be style challenged find my blog. I appreciate every one of you, and I consider you a friend.

Are You One Of The GURLS?

You will get a daily email reminder from me alerting you when a new blog post has gone live. And, occasionally, a “special” email will hit your inbox, so watch for those!

To GOD Goes The Glory!

Verse Of The Day

1 Corinthians 9:24 NIV

24 Do you not know that in a race all the runners run, but only one gets the prize? Run in such a way as to get the prize.

50 Is Not Old partners with affiliate platforms where commission may be earned based on clicks and or purchases, and I would love it if you decided to use the links above. Affiliate Links help bloggers like me fund the free content we provide on our blogs. As an Amazon Influencer, I earn from qualifying purchases. Some products might be gifted from brands.

50 Is Not Old Seal Logo

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

41 Comments

  1. Karen Burns says:

    You look great in bright pink!

  2. I just found your blog— it was so fun to see what stayed and what left the building!! lol. The nearest shopping is at the closest 1 hour away so I online shop sometimes too. And sometimes I just shop in my closet— I’ll start pulling stuff out and voila a “new” outfit appears!!

    1. Welcome, I hope you’re enjoying the blog.

  3. Ginger Hiller says:

    I enjoyed reading about the items you are not keeping and the reasoning. I am in the process of purging my closet because it is stuffed and there are numerous things that I have not worn this summer. There are also things that I loved when I bought them, but for one reason or another, I no longer love them. As a matter of fact, I hate walking in my closet due to it being packed. Not a good feeling, especially when there are so many people out there that don’t have 1/3 of what I have.

  4. Love the jacket and the blue sweater set. You look fabulous in all of the these. Do you have some new weight loss plan to share?

    1. Everyone keeps asking that, but I’ve actually gained some weight. I can’t figure it out.

  5. Vicki Farrell says:

    Love seeing all the different styles of jeans in particular. Like you I have few stores near me and do a lot of shopping online donuts nice to see your selections and the reasons you decided for or against.

  6. Totally appreciate the way you show all the fashion styles for us ladies! I almost feel you are one of my friends showing me outfits for me to wear. MC

  7. Stella Gustafson says:

    Thanks for sharing

  8. Good decisions on what to keep. I think you should keep the black Rebecca Mink off bag!!!! Lol

  9. Linda Shearer says:

    Thank You for this post it was so helpful. I liked hearing your thought processes on what to keep and what to send back. I loved every outfit you kept!

  10. Great outfits. My favorite was the houndstooth blazer with jeans.

  11. Oh my goodness Tania! You have me seriously doubting my “style eyes”! And I’m the one in our little group they call to take them shopping for events! The blackberry outfit (in my humble opinion) looks sooo cute on you. Of course I’m not there to really see well I guess. From my kitchen island though, it sure is adorable on you!

  12. I, like you, will continue to wear my long cardigans even if they aren’t the height of fashion! I love them with jeans and boots.

  13. Love your posts! I wish you were able to cater to petite sizes once in a while. I’m 4’11” I can only wear petite clothes.
    Love the long cardigans on you! Don’t forget to keep the leather dress!

    1. I’m trying to talk my beautiful DIL into styling petites for everyone. Maybe that will happen in the future.

  14. Love this post! I agree there are some things that look good but won’t wear enough. Now do you take things out of your closet? Like one for one

  15. I agree with items you sent back. I like the faux leather dress but I wouldn’t know where to wear it. Maybe if I lived in Dallas or even Austin. My area is too rural for head to toe leather. lol. I don’t blame you for sending it back.

  16. My fav’s, that not only do I think look amazing on you, but also which are looks I would duplicate (in my own colors): the blazer outfit, the blue longline cardigan outfit, the tan longline cardigan outfit, and the short sleeve cashmere sweater outfit. I also like the mint green cashmere sweater and the denim skirt as individual items. The eyeshadow trio you kept, also would work for me. I bookmarked it for consideration. 🙂 Thanks for sharing all your finds!

  17. I totally agree with all your “Keepers”…the slingback pumps are adorable!!! Happy Saturday ❤️❤️❤️

  18. Vicki from Oklahoma says:

    You look beautiful in everything. There’s a lot of good buys in the mix.

  19. It’s a hard decision on what to keep and what to send back. I like most of the outfits and totally agree with what you decided to keep. They all look very nice. You do look like you have lost some weight though. What are you doing for that? Just curious.

    1. I’ve not lost weight, but I’m trying. I have actually gained about 5-10 lbs. back, and I want to take those back off. It is a constant struggle, especially when you love to eat sweets.

  20. Lisa Mary Luciano says:

    I not only love getting inspiration from your outfits, but also your accessories! I need style help! Your blog always comes through!

  21. Roberta Schwandner says:

    I love these different fashions.

  22. Patt Dyal says:

    You should DEFINITELY keep the pleated skirt!! Such a beautiful outfit and it looks lovely on you. You can wear it to church or out to dinner. I vote for you to keep it!!! Hope that you will reconsider it.

  23. Love everything you showed today. You have a great eye and know what’s going to look good on you .

  24. Try a massage. They are so relaxing too! I love the Blue sleeveless sweater and the matching long cardigan outfit. Decisions, decisions. LIfe is tough. Lol

  25. You have chosen wisely. The items you kept look great on you and the ones you are returning, really weren’t that flattering. I do think you make most clothing look good! I have always said, when in doubt don’t buy it.

  26. Karen Johnson says:

    Everything is so cute. I really like the faux leather shirt dress

  27. This is such a great post. Everything looks great but love your reasoning behind returning items

  28. Lucky you having a facial. I don’t get them often, but when I do it is so wonderful!

  29. Everything looks great on you – hard to decide on keepers!

  30. I can see why you love the outfit with the longer cardigan. It looks fabulous on you! I love the chambray pants too. Great choices you are keeping. Love the leather look dress on you. Im like you, if I can’t get much wear out of it it’s going back.

  31. We don’t have a Nordstroms close by, but I have been shopping the Talbots Red Door Summer sale this way. I have wayyyyyyyyyyy more things than I need, but I love the looks.

  32. This was a fun, helpful post. I love the faux leather dress on you! I’d keep it 😊

    1. lol🤣 Every one seems to live that dress.

  33. Carol Ann Jablonski says:

    Wise decisions, especially about the double-breasted tweed jacket. Before you take the tags off the denim skirt, please sit down in it. Does it gap open or is that a problem that only I have? I was disappointed when you first posted your finds to see that when I clicked on many of the links that my size was not available. Rats, I thought some of the items would work for me too.

  34. I love the blue long cardigan set. It looks fabulous on you.

  35. Looks like you kept a lot of good items!